This weekend I was really looking forward to going to Costco and Winco and doing a price comparison on some items I commonly buy (and especially those I sometimes get in bulk from Costco). It was the most exciting weekend activity EVER. (Nerdy, I know.)
Since I know you're all as interested as me, I shall tell you the results. I was somewhat surprised by my findings, perhaps naively so. I really love Winco's bulk foods section and love that you can get however much you want or need of whatever it is you want or need. And I have noted that the prices of the bulk items per pound are cheaper than other places I've seen items sold by weight. I'm less impressed when I compare other areas of the store, though; however, the sales are often pretty good. Most of the items I compared were items you could find in the Winco bulk foods section.
Costco's worthiness was demonstrated in the comparison. (The comparisons are not all fair, I should say. Costco has better quality goods, generally speaking, but I tried to match the products as closely as possible.) Here are the results:
Costco | item | Winco |
1.08/lb | whole wheat spaghetti | .98/lb |
1.06/lb | penne | .76/lb |
1.96/lb | egg noodles | 1.10/lb |
2.22/lb (organic) | peanut butter | 1.48/lb (non-organic, self-churned) |
3.57/lb | almond butter | 3.96/lb |
1.66/gallon | milk | 1.88/gallon |
6.29/lb | pure maple syrup | 8.85/lb |
1.76/lb | semi-sweet chocolate chips | 2.21/lb |
2.33/lb | dried cranberries | 3.67/lb |
2.21/lb (name-brand) | honey nut cheerios | 1.79/lb |
.75/lb (organic) | apple sauce | .54/lb |
1.16/lb | short-grain brown rice | .74/lb |
.28/lb (for 25 lb bag) | long-grain white rice | .45/lb |
2.50/lb | quinoa | 3.52/lb |
2.00/lb | honey | 2.24/lb |
.69/lb (10 lbs) | oats | .51/lb |
4.22/gallon | soy milk | 5.12/gallon |
4.60/lb | walnuts | 3.30/lb |
5.28/lb | pecans | 8.50/lb |
3.33/lb | almonds | 3.78/lb |
.24/lb (for 25 lb bag) | all purpose flour | .27/lb |
.61/lb | sugar | .46/lb |
.81/lb | brown sugar | .97/lb |
18.62/gallon | olive oil | 28.62/gallon |
5.96/gallon | vegetable oil | 6.27/gallon |
6.32/gallon | canola oil | 7.18/gallon |
.62/lb | tomato sauce | .80/lb |
1.32/lb | tomato paste | 1.68/lb |
1.06/lb | diced tomatoes | 1.02/lb |
Some of the results were interesting. For example, although pecans and almonds are cheaper at Costco, walnuts are not. Pecans are significantly cheaper at Costco. Granulated sugar is quite a bit cheaper at Winco, and flour is comparable (I probably will still buy from Winco to avoid dealing with the 25 lb bag, though). I did not realize that canola oil is more expensive than vegetable oil. Brown rice is cheaper at Winco. Peanut butter is too, but almond butter is cheaper at Costco. I compared S&W canned garbanzo beans and black beans as well, and it turned out they were the same at both Costco and Winco: .68/can.
I hope you appreciated the results of my experiment. I guess shopping at Costco does save money after all. Which makes me feel a little better about paying to shop there? Hmm, I didn't factor that into the prices . . .